User Tools

Site Tools


thoughts_on_free_communication

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision
Previous revision
thoughts_on_free_communication [2013/02/22 19:46] mithatthoughts_on_free_communication [2013/03/18 00:20] (current) – [Criteria] mithat
Line 8: Line 8:
 ===== Motivation ===== ===== Motivation =====
   * Mobile data is almost ubiquitous.   * Mobile data is almost ubiquitous.
-  * Makes it possible to contemplate a free (as in speech) alternative to telecoms.+  * Makes it possible to contemplate a //[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gratis_versus_libre|libre]]// alternative to telecoms.
   * Communication means should be:   * Communication means should be:
     * decoupled from the data provider(s).     * decoupled from the data provider(s).
Line 17: Line 17:
     * Ideally **FOSS**.     * Ideally **FOSS**.
     * If self-hosting not possible, then an **open API** is possibly acceptable.     * If self-hosting not possible, then an **open API** is possibly acceptable.
-  * **Open standards** very much preferred. +  * **Open standards** 
-  * End-to-end **encryption** arguably mandatory.+  * **End-to-end encryption**
  
 ===== Criteria ===== ===== Criteria =====
-  * The service should offer:+  * The service(s) should offer:
     * **voice communication**     * **voice communication**
     * **text messaging**     * **text messaging**
Line 42: Line 42:
 ===== Evaluation ===== ===== Evaluation =====
   * **SIP**   * **SIP**
-    * Self-hosting: ?+    * Self-hosting: yes
     * Voice: yes     * Voice: yes
-    * Text: ?+    * Text: yes
     * Video: ?     * Video: ?
     * POTS: yes (provider dependent)     * POTS: yes (provider dependent)
Line 55: Line 55:
     * Video: yes     * Video: yes
     * POTS: yes     * POTS: yes
-    * Additional comments: Skype uses **closed-standard and proprietary codecs**. Others may also.+    * Comments: 
 +      * Skype uses closed-standard and proprietary codecs. Others may also.
  
-===== Evaluation =====+===== Evaluation (tabulated) =====
 |                              ^ Self-hosting ^ Voice ^ Text  ^ Video ^ POTS ^ |                              ^ Self-hosting ^ Voice ^ Text  ^ Video ^ POTS ^
-| //**XMPP + Jingle**//        | yes          | yes   | yes*  | yes   | no?  |   +| //**XMPP + Jingle**//        | yes          | yes   | yes   | yes   | no?  |   
-| //**SIP**//                  | ?            | yes   ?     | ?     | yes† |+| //**SIP**//                  | yes          | yes   yes   | ?     | yes† |
 | //**Integrated providers**// | no           | yes‡  | yes†† | yes   | yes  | | //**Integrated providers**// | no           | yes‡  | yes†† | yes   | yes  |
  
-*Not SMS\\ 
 †Provider dependent\\ †Provider dependent\\
 ‡Skype uses closed-standard and proprietary codecs. Others may also.\\ ‡Skype uses closed-standard and proprietary codecs. Others may also.\\
thoughts_on_free_communication.1361562383.txt.gz · Last modified: 2013/02/22 19:46 by mithat

Donate Powered by PHP Valid HTML5 Valid CSS Driven by DokuWiki